Reopening Three Mile Island nuclear plant for Microsoft data centers could cost taxpayers $1.6 billion

midian182

Posts: 10,265   +138
Staff member
A hot potato: It takes a massive amount of energy to power data centers, which is why Microsoft wants to tap the shuttered nuclear power plant on Three Mile Island for its AI ambitions. According to records, the owner of the plant is looking to secure a $1.6 billion federal loan guarantee to help finance the plan, money provided by taxpayer dollars.

The amount of energy being consumed by AI is well-documented, which is why many companies in the industry are looking toward nuclear power as a solution.

In September, Microsoft signed a deal to re-open the power plant on Three Mile Island, site of the worst nuclear meltdown in US history in 1979. The agreement stated that the tech giant would purchase all the power generated by the plant, which is being renamed the Crane Clean Energy Center.

Now, the Washington Post reports that the owner of the plant, utility company Constellation Energy, filed an application for a $1.6 billion federal loan guarantee with the US Department of Energy in May. The company previously said this amount would cover all the costs associated with reopening the plant, which closed in 2019. The application has cleared an initial review and has reached the stage where specific terms are being negotiated.

A loan guarantee means Constellation Energy will be borrowing money directly from the federal government, with the Energy Department acting as guarantor.

The Post explains that the loan would ensure federal financial support for the deal. This would be the case even if it fails to be completed and after a lot of money has been spent on the project, thereby shifting much of the risk of reopening the plant onto the taxpayers.

It's believed that the loan guarantee could save Constellation up to $122 million in borrowing costs for restarting the facility. That's in addition to the federal tax credits on the sale of the power, which could be worth nearly $200 million annually for Constellation and Microsoft.

If Constellation does accept the loan and fails to complete its repayments, the government will have to cover up to $1.6 billion in costs, though the company assures that this won't happen.

"Rest assured that to the extent we may seek a loan, Constellation will guarantee full repayment," Constellation said in a statement. "Any notion that taxpayers are taking on risk here is fanciful given that any loan will be backstopped by Constellation's entire $80-billion-plus value."

Constellation Energy said it plans to reopen Three Mile Island by 2028, supplying Microsoft with over 800 megawatts of carbon-free electricity across a 20-year agreement – provided the Nuclear Regulatory Commission gives its approval.

In January last year, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission gave its approval for the first small modular nuclear reactor to be built in the United States. NuScale Power Corp says its six-reactor, 462-megawatt Carbon Free Power Project should be operational by 2030. It's hoped that small nuclear reactors like these could be used to solve data centers' sustainable power problem.

Permalink to story:

 
"We live in an age of poverty, greed, violence, destruction. Indeed, the very seat of the federal government, Washington D.C., has been reduced to what is now known as the "Capital Wasteland." The Capital Wasteland... How did it come to this, America? How did your leaders allow the most powerful nation on Earth… to die? The answer is really quite simple: Incompetence. Incompetence at the highest echelons of power. We put our trust, our faith, in halfwits. Our intrepid leaders had everything they wanted! Power. Wealth. Prestige. And it made them lazy, America. Oh yes, and laziness breeds stupidity. Rest assured, I will not make the mistakes of my predecessors. When John Henry Eden builds a country, he builds it to last. The American way."
 
“As democracy is perfected, the office of president represents, more and more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the White House will be adorned by a downright m0ron.”
― H.L. Mencken, On Politics: A Carnival of Buncombe
 
Could you please stop the ridiculous hyperbole in the headlines?

"...the worst nuclear accident in US history..."

About that:
"the accident resulted in no deaths or injuries to plant workers or in nearby communities"

Three Mile Island was a partial meltdown, but there wasn't an explosion or anything like the Chernobyl disaster which killed 30 within three months of the incident with a possibility of many more after.

The US Government has around $200 Billion in such loans out right now and the plan to reopen the plant hasn't been executed, yet. Why the stupid headline that's creating drama where there isn't any?
 
On average a ChatGPT query takes 10x the energy of a simple Google search. If we want to implement AI solutions we are going to need to get the power from somewhere.
 
Could you please stop the ridiculous hyperbole in the headlines?

"...the worst nuclear accident in US history..."

About that:
"the accident resulted in no deaths or injuries to plant workers or in nearby communities"

Three Mile Island was a partial meltdown, but there wasn't an explosion or anything like the Chernobyl disaster which killed 30 within three months of the incident with a possibility of many more after.

The US Government has around $200 Billion in such loans out right now and the plan to reopen the plant hasn't been executed, yet. Why the stupid headline that's creating drama where there isn't any?

- but but but... rage sells!
 
Could you please stop the ridiculous hyperbole in the headlines?

"...the worst nuclear accident in US history..."

About that:
"the accident resulted in no deaths or injuries to plant workers or in nearby communities"

Three Mile Island was a partial meltdown, but there wasn't an explosion or anything like the Chernobyl disaster which killed 30 within three months of the incident with a possibility of many more after.

The US Government has around $200 Billion in such loans out right now and the plan to reopen the plant hasn't been executed, yet. Why the stupid headline that's creating drama where there isn't any?

"Engagement" my dude. They got you to engage and yep, me too.
 
On average a ChatGPT query takes 10x the energy of a simple Google search. If we want to implement AI solutions we are going to need to get the power from somewhere.

How much is a Google search now though, since they implement AI into every search?
 
Was curious where it actually was, near Harrisburg on the Susquehanna River,prevailing wind maybe hits Philadelphia. Apparently they decontaminated the water and evaporated it off, so seems a nice solution as river is a source for drinking water, as well as an ecological biome .
Modern Nuclear power stations are pretty safe, but anyone believes that budget to bring in online needs to be sold the Brooklyn Bridge
 
This is Microsoft....why not just use solar panels and windmills? They can afford it They can buy Nebraska for the surface area needed.
 
O'er the land of the free and the home of the brave where corruption is legalized by the lobby law?
I pay your campain and you make a nice law for me to get 1000 times the money back.

What can go wrong?
 
I don't think we have much choice. We need the power. Our grids are already very old, and almost at capacity!
 
I'm in favor of Nuclear Power, but to dole out taxpayer funds used to just assist one of the most profitable corporations in the world is misuse.
 
Could you please stop the ridiculous hyperbole in the headlines?

"...the worst nuclear accident in US history..."

About that:
"the accident resulted in no deaths or injuries to plant workers or in nearby communities"

Three Mile Island was a partial meltdown, but there wasn't an explosion or anything like the Chernobyl disaster which killed 30 within three months of the incident with a possibility of many more after.
I agree the headline is ridiculous. It also fails to make the distinction between a pretty-well backstopped loan and a grant.

But what almost happened at Three Mile Island should be a continuing concern. I'm not against nuclear power. I look at how the Navy manages its reactors and I come away with the sense that serious people with the right mindset - and multiple layers of no-nonsense oversight - can pull it off. But TMI was a different scenario. The impression I have there is private ownership, looking to shave dollars, cut corners, looked the other way, lied, and courted disaster. The disaster may have stopped just short of the finish line but playing it off as minor isn't right either.
 
Back